Alexis (along with Todd, Dex, Janet, and Freddy) appeared in the episode, "School Spirit," only to turn villainous in "Full Moon Halloween." In the latter episode, Freddy invited the rest of the group to his new house, which resembled a haunted house, and later revealed that he suspects one of them of being the werewolf that was plaguing the town--one of its' victims being his younger brother. Freddy used little furry creatures called "plogs" to find out who the werewolf is, and one of them bites Alexis. Alexis denies being a werewolf, and stated earlier in the episode that she had to get home because she had a curfew. After finding instructions in the box the plogs came from, the group concluded that Alexis was bitten because the plogs had been exposed to light for too long, and it was at that moment that the plogs became rabid and went all over the house.
After capturing all of them, the rest of the group left while Freddy looked around for Alexis, whom he found upstairs in the attic, staring at the full moon. At that moment, the evil Alexis transformed into a werewolf, proving the plogs correct and cementing Alexis' heel turn. After her transformation, Alexis attacked and (assumingly) killed Freddy.
- Madeline Zima also appeared as wicked stepsister Brianna Montgomery in the teen dramedy A Cinderella Story.