Brooke debuted for TNA in 2010, but she would become a villainess in 2013, when she resurfaced as the girlfriend of Aces and Eights leader Bully Ray. Brooke mostly served as the valet for the entire faction, but she would defeat Velvet Sky to earn an opportunity at the Knockouts Championship later on. Brooke's title opportunity came at Bound For Glory that year against ODB and Gail Kim, but she was defeated and pinned by Gail.
Aces and Eights disbanded in the end of 2013, but Brooke maintained her villainous persona in matches since then, including a loss to Velvet Sky on an edition of Xplosion. In 2014, the evil Brooke competed at the second Knockouts Knockdown event against Deonna Purrazzo, who she bullied and berated in a promo before their match began. Brooke went on to defeat Deonna to advance to the Queen of the Knockouts Battle Royal, which was won by Madison Rayne.