While the original werewolf moved on, Kelly remained and adjusted to her life as a werewolf herself; claiming to be in control of her transformations until the last few nights. In her bestial state, Kelly hunted and killed several citizens, and was shot on her right leg by new sheriff (and potential love interest) Phil Jenkins.
Kelly is revealed as the werewolf when Phil sees the wound on her right leg. After her reveal, Kelly (in partial werewolf form) lunged after Phil, but she is shot and subdued. She regains her full human form and convinces Pam that Phil is the werewolf and tells her to shoot him, which she does. Phil survives because he was wearing a bulletproof vest, but at that moment, the evil Kelly flashes her green eyes and fangs as she rips Pam's entrails out. Kelly then fully transforms into a werewolf and devours Pam, but she is later burned to death by Phil and werewolf hunter Quinn McKenzie.