Okie Annie is part of "conniving cowboy of crime" Shame's gang. They start out by stealing various auto parts from a go kart, hot rod and racing car with intentions of building a vehicle that can go 300mph, and as such, outrun the Batmobile. Their next target is Bruce Wayne's limousine. Annie finds the millionaire and his ward in a French lingerie shop and poses as a helpful customer, with the added request that they give her a lift. On the way, however, Shame and his gang ambush Wayne and steal his vehicle; lacking the knowledge that a tracking device was implanted inside by it's owner.Batman and Robin follow the villains to their hideout, located at a bankrupt former movie studio called "Westernland". A brawl ensues between the men, while Annie steps aside to play cheerleader. Nevertheless, the villainess ends up turning the tides when she shoots her rifle up at the ceiling and brings a wooden chandelier crashing down onto the dynamic duo. Shame arranges for the incapacitated heroes to be killed by a stampede of cattle.
Batman and Robin escape and deduce that Shame's primary goal is to steal four prized Black Angus cattle to sell to some "unscrupulous cattle ranchers". The villains succeed, but only temporarily, as the crimefighters manage to trail them to the K.O. Corral. Annie and the entirity of Shame's gang open fire, but a quick smokebomb from Batman soon leaves them with empty chambers. Finally, Commissioner Gordon shows up and has the gang arrested.