After Mia is held captive by Izzy and Adrian, Pam went with Reid to rescue her, but it was at the scene that Pam's true villainous role is revealed to Reid. With Adrian killed by Izzy, the evil Pam planned to kill both Reid and Izzy, making it appeared that Reid was killed by Izzy, while Pam had to kill Izzy in self defense. Her evil plan was thwarted when Mia appeared and sprayed a foreign substance in Pam's eyes, which led to Pam accidentally shooting Reid's left leg. The villainess escapes and leaves Izzy to be mauled by a bear, but she later reappeared and attacked Mia, while planning to kill her. Partially blinded, Pam shot various wild shots before she is finally defeated by Mia. Pam was tied up in Izzy's drug room while Mia tended to Reid, and she was later arrested.
- Vanessa Vander Pluym later appeared as The Queen of Hearts in an episode of The Librarians.