Taeler debuted for Queens of Combat during their first show on March 21, 2014, and became a villainess when she entered the Qoc Title Tournament in June 2015. She defeated Amy Love in the first round at Queens of Combat 5, and defeated Amanda Rodriguez in the quarterfinals at Queens of Combat 6, all while taunting Amanda by flirting with Amanda's boyfriend, Caleb Konley, cementing Taeler as a wicked villainess.
At Queens of Combat 7 on November 29, 2015, the evil Taeler defeated Candice LeRae in the semifinals, and later defeated Tessa Blanchard in the finals to become the first ever Queens of Combat Champion. Taeler successfully defended the title at Queens of Combat 8 against Allysin Kay, but lost a non title four way match to Tessa Blanchard at Queens of Combat 9. On April 1, 2016, Taeler successfully defended the title against Tessa Blanchard and Jessicka Havok in a three-way match, after Taeler capitalized on Havok's offense and pinned Tessa. A month later, Taeler retained her title against Candice LeRae and Jessicka Havok on back-to-back shows.
Taeler began appearing for Ring of Honor in 2015, serving as the villainous valet to Truth Martini and becoming the lone female member of the House of Truth. Taeler also competes for the Women of Honor division, beginning with defeating Mandy Leon, starting a rivalry between the two. After being challenged to another match months later, Taeler was defeated by Mandy, leading to the villainess attacking Mandy with a steel chair after the match.
- Taeler Hendrix's current villainous look draws comparisons to Batman villainess Poison Ivy.